One of America's best conducting talents is currently Principal Conductor at Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra in England. Over the past few days, the "other BSO", the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra has been trying to lure her back to her native soil, but it has all turned into a media disaster for all concerned as the members of orchestra have publicly implied that they don't like her.
The root of the problem stems from the orchestra's recent pay negotiations with the musicians. The orchestra has built up about a $10 million deficit, so in return for a 10% pay cut, the musicians were promised a bigger say in who will conduct them. So after the recent retirement of Yuri Temirkanov, a 21 member search committee was formed, including 7 members of the orchestra. The search committee was to recommend Marin Alsop to the Orchestra's board for appointment and rumours of this spread last Friday.
James Glicker, president of the Baltimore Symphony admitted opinions in the orchestra about potential candidates was "volatile". This bore out on Saturday, when Jane Marvine, head of the BSO players committee announced to the press:
Our understanding is that the seven musician members of the search committee who represent the sentiments of the orchestra members are unanimous in their view that a decision at this time is premature and that the search process should continue.
Which to me sounds like they really don't like her. It's funny, because I understand she's quite liked in Bournemouth. In a recent conversation with a principal player there, he described her as,
a straight talking character with a clear technique and a withering glance - particularly if you are a member of the audience trying to unwrap a throat sweet rather too noisily.

The board confirmed on Tuesday that she was to be appointed, and the Baltimore Sun said they had ignored "the objections of the majority of the orchestra's musicians". Meanwhile, Alsop seemed pleased:
I've looked forward to working with the world-class musicians of the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra with a special excitement since the first time I conducted them
I can't believe she's not heard the dispute with the players, yet she described them as:
exceptional, committed and passionate about what they do. And, with the board and staff, they make a great team."
In the past Alsop has been quoted as saying:
I am more of a colleague than a maestro
So perhaps this attitude will help her break down the frostiness when she arrives there in 2007.
UPDATE 22nd July:The Baltimore Sun is
reporting that before signing the contract, Marin Alsop spoke to the players to ask for their support, to which they offered "110%".